Poppi Picts from Emigre

It's hard not to think of Susan Kare when I see these. Perhaps her work was an influence.

Is anybody else disappointed?

hhp

Both works are wicked! Both are a complete collention of usable symbols. But, i see big differences in your styles and angles. For example, one of them is smoooth, and the oder is more "no alias" style.

Is anybody else disappointed?

I am a bit disappointed. Emigre's work is usually more, I don't know, different. Now we've got a 777-member pictogram family. Yippy Skippy, just what I want!

Although, the breadth of the project does seem remarkably Emigre-like, even if the content does not.

The world is not static and Emigre have the right to be different! Its a good sign. Glad that they are far away from Emperor and others earlier bitmaps families. They bring many gems along their long career.

But yes, I'm bit surprised too by the non-style of theses pictograms.

>Is anybody else disappointed?

Not really, as I have never had great expectations of pictograms. But I see what you mean, and this project, though current, prolific, and useful in its content matter, is somewhat flat stylistically, treading no new ground from the FF Dingbats of 10 years ago.

Another thing that makes it seem old fashioned is that a ghastly toon-ism has afflicted icon-making in recent years, with excessive detail, multi-colors, and dimensionalization, so Poppi's austerity of rendering, while it makes all kinds of sense to purists, may have to wait for the pendulum to swing back. Let's hope utility wins out over flashiness, though, and this is a great success!

whatever anybody thinks about the style and quality, Poppi is gonna sell like crazy, i'm sure!

> Emigre have the right to be different!

Different than what? This isn't really different than other font houses - quite the contrary - this is something that could have come from a number of other places. This is just different than Emigre itself! I've had high expectations of them since their recent return to type, and I think they did much better with Tribute for example.

> Poppi is gonna sell like crazy

Exactly.

hhp

It's a nice exercise, but I don't have any practical need for such a set. I'm more interested in icons specifically designed for GUI, such as these from CSA Design alum Paul Howalt:

> It’s a nice exercise, but I don’t have any practical need for such a set.

I was just thinking that it would be really cool if they sold each icon separately. Sure, it would be a pain in the ass, but I'd be more likely to buy one that I really needed for $20-30 than pay a higher amount and end up with a bunch of icons that I might not use.

Other than that, I really like the set. It has an oxymoronic wicked innocence to it.

I got a pretty good laugh at the "censored" type specimen they sent in the mail.