Nameplate set in Sutro Deluxe and Initials from Parkinson. Your typeface could be next. Learn more.
Ads via The Deck
Commentary

Scher Makes Up With Helvetica?

Stephen Coles on August 28, 2007

HP_Modern

I have mixed feelings about these free business templates Paula Scher just designed for HP. On one hand, she’s helping to improve the look of small business — a landscape dominated by clumsy MS Word and Publisher templates. On the other, she’s contributing to the false notion that you don’t really need a relationship with a skilled designer to create your identity: beautiful letterheads and business cards tailored to your company can just come straight out of the computer with no professional input at all.

But what puzzles me most is why Scher chose Helvetica for two of the five templates. She seems to avoid it in her own work, and hated on it pretty openly in the Helvetica film, in which she called it the typeface of the conservative establishment and (jokingly) the cause of the Vietnam and Iraq wars.

Perhaps it’s her subversive way of saying that if you’re a business that uses templates for your identity, you are part of the establishment. So, here, have Helvetica — it fits you.

21 Comments

  1. Dan Mall says:

    Perhaps its her subversive way of saying that if you’re a business that uses templates, you are part of the establishment. So here, have Helvetica. It fits you.

    I’ll buy that reasoning. I don’t always like the typefaces that I use, but some are just appropriate. The HP templates are potentially something that everyone can use. Sounds like a job for Helvetica to me.

  2. I love that Sher chose Helvetica. Though I do not necessarily agree with the feelings she expressed in the Helvetica film a part of me internally smirks at the idea that she purposefully slipped the typeface in…

    “No template is a substitute for hiring a professional designer,” warns Scher, and indeed at Scher’s suggestion the HP site includes a prominent link to the AIGA designer directory. “But at the very least, I hope we can stop a few innocent people out there from using Comic Sans.”

    Helvetica vs comic sans… One typeface may say “you sold out to the man”, but the other is a visual assault on the eyes.

  3. Tom says:

    sadly it’s not always up to the designer what face is used…even prestigious designers. someone somewhere probably said use helvetica…aside from the fact it’s a common face that most users (in this case) will have so they can match it…opposed to franklin gothic. which funny enough most people who use the templates probably wouldn’t know, let alone see the difference even if the two were on the same page.

    we’ve fallen into a real sad time for print design and typography i’m afraid.

  4. Hrant says:

    Subversive, or sell-out?

    hhp

  5. Chris Rugen says:

    I’d guess she did it to be snide, in a subtle, subjective, designer-y way. Having read her writing about her work, it would fit.

    As for being a sell-out? She does commercial and corporate ID for a living. The vast majority of designers don’t ‘sell out’. That implies that we seek to do something other than be bought in the first place.

  6. Caren Litherland says:

    Subversive gets my vote. Kind of in the same way that antebellum spirituals were sung openly, but were in fact laden with pointed subversive messages.

  7. Thomas Moes says:

    I must admit i share your mixed feelings concerning the idea of creating Free business templates.

    This gives the false idea that choosing your business identity is as easy as choosing a christmas card.

    I reckon it might work well for newbie design students though. It could give them an idea how to design for a certain company (I know i would have liked it). It reminds me of the chapter in ‘Stop Steeling Sheep’ where they try to explain Angry and Happy with different fonts.

  8. Hmm. I tried this out, but I really don’t see much difference between this and various MS Word templates. In some ways, its even less usable, as they’re just downloadable PDFs. Do I print these and use them in my, um, typewriter, then? Clearly this is more a splash for HP printers (which I have and enjoy).

  9. Randy Jones says:

    We humans are a group of lockstep individuals. We want to be perceived as cool and normal at the same time. Helvetica is the perfect choice for the conflicted.

  10. Well put, Randy. As good as any quote in the movie — and it was full of pithy stuff.

  11. My best guess is that these fonts were selected because everyone has them. If they are free, and will be made available in an editable format, then those “templates” would have the same common denominator as, say, a webpage.

    I think these templates are a horrible idea. The same thing is happening on the web right now with the whole “Web 2.0″ plastic-look going on. When the bar is lowered to include “cookie-cutter” as a viable alternative, it takes ten-seconds too long to figure out if what you are looking at is a real business – or some highschool kid. Again, it isn’t that what we are looking at IS a viable alternative. It is the lowering of the bar that simple confounds the viewer.

  12. Craig says:

    Perhaps it’s her subversive way of saying that if you’re a business that uses templates for your identity, you are part of the establishment. So here, have Helvetica. It fits you.

    “It is as if a man were to say ‘As you are bent upon cutting your throat, I beg you to take this new and perfectly sharp razor and make as efficient a job of it as you possibly can.'”

    Anyone want to guess the source?

  13. doesntmatter says:

    I don’t want to guess, but I’d like to know.

  14. alexis g says:

    i guess it would have been more interesting instead of imagining static letterheads that could eventually fit to what the designer thinks “small business companies” might need or enjoy as letterheads to let the user combine different things as a lego game, for example, or make some randomness happen in the page maybe (not possible in a pdf, right, it should have been some web app in this case i guess).

    In this situation she would have been more in the position of a designer i think.

    What i mean (and i hope i’m clear enough) is that, it’s Scher position as a designer that is questionable in this case; and i think what you describe Stephen as problematic, is the result of that and not the cause.

    Anyway i think we all agree those pdf won’t be used anyway, but it do nothing to help people understand what a designer can help them in their business.

  15. Craig says:

    The quotation above was Beatrice Warde talking about Eric Gill’s gift of Gill Sans to industry, 1933.

  16. bec says:

    So if Helvetica and sterile one-fits-alls are overtaking the primary school publisher look, doesn’t this mean good things for us? Maybe the fact that these templates are available means that when clients come to us for business cards we are challenged to produce something beyond this? That this is no longer the safe look, but the unsophisticated look? That we might be able to produce something relevant to them that excites us? Go the templates I reckon- if it means that we have to do less of it, I’m all for it.

  17. Alan says:

    While I think it’s great for Scher to promote the value inherent in having well-designed material, and she states on the pentagram blog that “No template is a substitute for hiring a professional designer” (where she also apparently is slamming Comic Sans, not Helvetica, at present), HP is the same company that created and powers Stinkylogo.com, a cheap, fast designers-crammed-into-a-dark- room-and-forced-to-create-an-entire- brand-identity-in-one-week-for-peanuts-sort of place. How does Scher reconcile promoting good design when her presence at HP helps to legitimize the dark underbelly called stinkylogo.com? Good design can come cheap, but do you really think someone can create something perfect for a client with almost no research into their business, in under a week?

  18. Martin says:

    I must say, at a first glace these remind me of a few of the presets in Apple’s Pages which also makes use of Helvetica (Neue, especially, if memory serves me right).
    When I first saw some of the letter templates in pages, I thought “hm, this looks pretty nice,” but I haven’t seen them used extensively in any way. What we could end up with was the godawful Pagemaker 1 look, where boxes with rounded corners suddenly were EVERYWHERE.

  19. wow, alan, i didn’t know this site. I knew some shocking logo sites but knowing there’s HP behind it is far more shocking site. In general such sites are based in romania�

    anyway the name of the site is true : logos that stinks !

  20. Rekobeko says:

    I think the templates offer an opportunity to appreciate design at its basic level.

    If anything Scher may be helping good design reach a wider audience or a wider acceptance.

    The templates are very, very basic. But design wise, thought out, balanced and professionally designed by a well-respected designer.

    That ultra simplicity offers the user of a very clean but safe design for when time, budget and other factors simply do not allow for the hiring of a pro-designer.

    Perhaps that simplicity, that bare-bones design inspires the user(s) to consider a higher level of design and detail. The templates could be the first step for people to appreciate better design.

    As for HP’s Stinkylogo, its debatable. On one side you have decent templates making it out to the world.

    On the other and more important side, template sites do promote a devaluation of the effort of design and the profession in genral. It also makes non-designers or people, organizations that do not understand the complexity of design to think that design doesnt require time or much thought and/or effort.

    Thats the biggest danger to the profession. But HPs site and others of its ilk are non the only ones at fault. Computers and graphics software in general promote super-fast graphic design. And if you’re fast on the computer the better to their eyes!

    People that do not understand the design process often plan out projects and create deadlines that literally do not consider a design process.

    Thus enters these templates. Its a shame and something that needs to be addressed in the design community. Especially from input and support from elder designers such as Paula.

  21. Josh says:

    I realize this is an old article, but I thought it worth mentioning that Scher has answered this question several times: She originally designed the HP templates with Gotham, but H& F-J wouldn’t agree to embedding it due to the probability that it would get ripped off; they didn’t want that since it was/is their top-selling typeface. Thus, Helvetica was her choice.

    However, that still doesn’t answer: Why not use something else? To my knowledge she has not answered that question sufficiently. She just says it was “the obvious choice” for the requirements. And I can understand that.

    Something else strikes me, though. Why have very few gotten upset at Apple’s templates in Pages? Sure, they’re better, but it’s the same theory — democratizing design sans the individualized partnership with the designer. Does the same sentiment exist concerning Apple?

    Most will not pay for a designer, but would still like a professional look for their business. And many just can’t afford it now; they may be in the beginning stages, so they teach themselves, and often that starts with studying work that is already well done, such as a template designed by a professional. I’m okay with that for a short season. Hopefully the time will come when they realize they need to progress past that initial and elementary step.

Post a Comment

Comments at Typographica are moderated and copyedited, just like a “Letter to the Editor” in a newspaper. Abusive or off-topic comments will not be published. Compliments are appreciated, but will not be published unless they add to the conversation. Thank you!

Recently Commented
Colophon

Typographica is a review of typefaces and type books, with occasional commentary on fonts and typographic design. Edited by Stephen Coles and designed by Chris Hamamoto. Founded in 2002 by Joshua Lurie-Terrell. Relaunched in 2009 by Coles and Hamamoto.

Set in Bureau Grot by Font Bureau, Nocturno Display by Nikola Djurek, Fern (unreleased) by David Jonathan Ross, and JAF Bernini Sans by Tim Ahrens.

Brought to you by this month’s nameplate sponsor, FontShop, MyFonts, FontFont, Wordpress, Fused, and the letter B. Read our editorial policy.

Elsewhere